Dutch authorities allegedly seize VPN server without a warrant — company claims that law enforcement will return it after analyzing the device fully

Windscribe logo
(Image credit: Windscribe)

Canada-based Windscribe, a VPN provider, just said that one of its European servers has been allegedly seized by Dutch authorities without a warrant. According to the company’s post on X, law enforcement said that they will return it to the service provider after they “fully analyze it.” It’s unclear why law enforcement impounded just a single rack from Windscribe’s cabinet, but the VPN provider said that it only uses RAM disk servers, meaning anyone who would look through the installed SSDs would only find a stock Ubuntu install on it, so the servers shouldn't hold any trackable data.

“THIS IS NOT A DRILL: The Dutch authorities, without a warrant, just seized one of our VPN servers saying they’ll give it back after they ‘fully analyze it’,” the company said in its social media post. “Windscribe uses RAM disk servers so that only thing the authorities will find is a stock Ubuntu install.”

The company maintains on its website that it doesn’t keep personal data about the activity of its users. Aside from that, it also says, “Our Transparency Report tracks real-time data requests from copyright and law enforcement agencies. To date, we have complied with zero requests, due to lack of relevant data.”

It’s unclear what the Dutch authorities seek from Windscribe’s server, but the company said in a subsequent X post that it gets “a handful of law enforcement requests every month” and that it always responds with “we have no logs.” However, the company claims that the authorities didn’t ask this time, saying that “they just snatched the server from the rack to look for the logs themselves.”

RAM cannot retain data after it loses power, which is why security-conscious companies use it over traditional SSDs and hard drives. But other X users were quick to point out that “it is standard practice to keep a seized server powered on or otherwise technically accessible until investigators can perform a live memory (RAM) capture in a forensic lab.”

We do not know what the Dutch authorities want to get from Windscribe’s servers, but this event will test the extent of the protections that it offers to its users. But no matter how great a VPN service is, it still cannot offer complete anonymity unless the user takes specific actions on their end to completely protect their identity. We reached out to Windscribe for comment and will update if they respond.

Google Preferred Source

Follow 3DTested on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.

Jowi Morales
Contributing Writer
  • hwertz
    Is that REALLY standard to practice to keep a seized server powered on, or is that standard practice in some TV show or movie? Riddle me this, how do you yank a server out of a rack without cutting power to it?
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    hwertz said:
    Is that REALLY standard to practice to keep a seized server powered on, or is that standard practice in some TV show or movie? Riddle me this, how do you yank a server out of a rack without cutting power to it?
    Well, you don't just go all gorilla and "yank it out"

    One way would be to disconnect its UPS from the original wall power and plug it into power that the authorities control.

    Trivial...I could to this with my PC at home. I could move it across the country without powering off.
    Reply
  • ODuffer
    Hopefully the first thing WS do on hearing 'the knock' is pull the plug.
    Reply
  • ButtermilkBiscuit
    Must not of seen the Seinfeld "Frogger" episode...
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    ODuffer said:
    Hopefully the first thing WS do on hearing 'the knock' is pull the plug.
    Why would a reputable business doing nothing nefarious automagically disconnect everything when hearing a knock at the door?

    Oh wait....
    Reply
  • Wwwyzzerdd
    hwertz said:
    Is that REALLY standard to practice to keep a seized server powered on, or is that standard practice in some TV show or movie? Riddle me this, how do you yank a server out of a rack without cutting power to it?
    Servers are built with redundancy; they have two separate power supplies so that if one fails, the other will continue powering the unit. Simply disconnect one from UPS and plug in to portable UPS.
    Reply
  • bill001g
    It would not take much for them to add a feature that powers off the machine or wipes the memory if it the machine is idle for a period of time. This is how the graphene os for pixel phones prevent extraction of data from stolen or confiscated phones.
    Reply
  • RPGpro
    Wwwyzzerdd said:
    Servers are built with redundancy; they have two separate power supplies so that if one fails, the other will continue powering the unit. Simply disconnect one from UPS and plug in to portable UPS.
    This wouldn't work if the server has even basic security features enabled.
    Most servers will automatically perform a soft power down if they lose the connection to their domain controller, this is designed to ensure data which is being processed and hasn't been encrypted yet can't be accessed.
    But it's a system that's also frequently used for power saving even when data isn't sensitive, since if a server can't access required data it might as well power down until needed.
    In the case of RAM-based storage this usually means the server power down also deletes the data...
    Reply
  • Joomsy
    USAFRet said:
    Why would a reputable business doing nothing nefarious automagically disconnect everything when hearing a knock at the door?

    Oh wait....
    Ah, yes, guilty until proven innocent. Lemme guess; you're also one of these types who are fine with Microsoft handing over decryption keys to the government because "if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry about". Do you also let strange people into your house when you spot them creeping around your yard? I mean, if you have nothing to steal, you've got nothing to worry about, right? You should be totally fine with absolute strangers pilfering through your personal property.
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    Joomsy said:
    Ah, yes, guilty until proven innocent. Lemme guess; you're also one of these types who are fine with Microsoft handing over decryption keys to the government because "if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry about". Do you also let strange people into your house when you spot them creeping around your yard? I mean, if you have nothing to steal, you've got nothing to worry about, right? You should be totally fine with absolute strangers pilfering through your personal property.
    Sorry, but you are so far wrong....
    Reply